Friends of Prouty Garden today announced they would not appeal the Massachusetts Appeals Court’s April 19th decision which upheld the Superior Court’s dismissal of their complaint about the state Department of Public Health’s slack regulatory process and its role in Boston Children’s Hospital’s $1 billion expansion project. The decision effectively ends a four-year legal battle to preserve the historic Prouty Garden, which served as a tranquil oasis for ailing children and their families for more than 50 years.
This week, Boston Children's Hospital unveiled its new rooftop garden. The space contains a small patch of grass, paved walkways, tables and chairs, and some potted plants. It may be a nice space, but it lacks nearly everything a therapeutic healing garden should contain.
This afternoon, Suffolk Superior Court Judge Janet L. Sanders will hear arguments on two closely-related motions filed by the Ten Taxpayer Group comprising Friends of the Prouty Garden in its pending lawsuit against Boston Children’s Hospital (BCH) and state public health officials. With the parties’ legal briefs already on file with the court, this will essentially be the hearing on the merits of the Prouty Garden court case.
In addition to violating Condition 8 of the DoN, the lawsuit alleges that the hospital began construction activities associated with the new tower without written approval from DPH of preliminary and final architectural plans, as required by state law, and that BCH failed to implement a plan for communicating the status of the expansion project to community groups, as required by another DoN condition.
The Prouty Garden at Boston Children’s Hospital was such a treasure and during the week of this year’s Earth Day, it provided a fragmentary piece of evidence testifying to its deep value. The tree, symbolically, and perhaps in a true and real spiritual sense, drew in the worst of those fears and the deepest of despair and gave back hope and confirmation that there is more to our existence than just our physiological well-being. Love, courage, faith, compassion, hope, patience, endurance and a myriad of other qualities play a far greater role in determining whether we live a “good life” or not. The Prouty Garden was a place where one could go to confirm that truth every day.
Thomas Farragher has a powerful column in today's Boston Globe. Please go read it right away, comment and share it with your friends who care about this issue. His column begins, "Those loud cheers you heard along Longwood Avenue this week were coming from the corporate suite inside Boston Children’s Hospital. What a pity. It didn’t have to be this way"
We are disappointed that the Public Health Council voted yesterday afternoon to allow the Boston Children's Hospital's $1 billion expansion plan to move forward without any substantive or credible analysis of the consequences. This massive project would increase the price of hospital care, reduce competition, and expose Massachusetts consumers and taxpayers to untold millions of dollars in additional heath care costs. It would also destroy a beautiful, unique therapeutic healing garden that has given give solace to generations of sick children and their families.
Friends, the Public Health Council is voting TOMORROW on whether Children's should be allowed to build the most expensive hospital expansion in state history. To fully understand all of what's at stake tomorrow, today's Boston Globe column by Joan Vennochi is an absolute MUST READ. If this matters to you, then we hope you will join us TOMORROW at our RALLY TO SAVE PROUTY GARDEN. 12:30 pm in front of the State House. The will of the people will be heard.
The Friends of Prouty Garden (FPG) today called on the state to delay a vote on the controversial $1 billion Boston Children’s Hospital (BCH) expansion plan to assess a better alternative, the Shattuck Patient Building, that would meet the needs of the hospital and minimize the likely risk of driving up health care costs in Massachusetts.
Here is a wonderful poem sent to us by a the mother of a former Children's patient. In her note to us, Paula wrote, "My daughter battled cancer for over two years before her death in 2013. Over that two year period she spent many days at Boston's Children's Hospital for hydration, fevers, pneumonia, etc. We were there almost on a weekly basis for several days. Our longest stay spanned over two weeks. The Prouty garden was an oasis in the midst of this medical crisis."
On Thursday, Oct. 20, at 2 p.m., the MA Public Health Council will meet to vote on the DPH staff recommendation to approve the BCH's ill-conceived expansion project. Please join our RALLY on the sidewalk directly in front of the MA State House on Beacon Street, Boston from 12:30 p.m. - 1:30 p.m., on Thursday, Oct. 20. After the rally, we will march to the Public Health Council meeting at 250 Washington Street, and show our support for sending BCH back to the drawing board!
A former Boston Children's Hospital volunteer shared her memory of the Prouty Garden this weekend in Boston Globe Magazine. Her story touches upon the intangible thing that those who have found solace in the Prouty Garden have trouble articulating. It is a sense of wonder that exists in that half-acre healing space. The delight of discovering a hidden statue or fountain, a private shady spot to sit, a bug or a bird or a bunny.
"THIS IS NOT about a garden. Not anymore." So opens today's Boston Globe column by Joan Venocchi on what Boston Children's Hospital's proposed expansion project will mean for the pediatric care market in Boston and Massachusetts. "Giving Boston Children’s Hospital the go-ahead for a $1 billion expansion plan will alter the health care landscape beyond a patch of beloved green space. Expansion would allow Children’s to further dominate the pediatric care market, hurt competitors, and drive up health care costs."
A Boston Herald article published on Saturday, "Prouty backers cry foul on DPH," took a critical look at the recommended approval. Members of an advocacy group attempting to block Boston Children’s Hospital’s $1 billion planned expansion said the state’s recent recommendation to approve those plans is ill-informed, based on skewed information from the hospital itself. “In effect, the staff has relied on what the hospital provided while giving no weight to outside experts,” said Greg McGregor, lead counsel for the Ten Taxpayer Group and Friends of Prouty Garden.
We are disappointed that the staff at the Department of Public Health recommended approval of the $1 billion expansion of Children's Hospital without any substantive or credible analysis of the consequences, ignoring both significant concerns raised by the state's own Health Policy Commission, and objections raised by thousands of patients, families, community members, donors and staff who comprise the Friends of the Prouty Garden.
For the first time ever, the Massachusetts Health Policy Commission (HPC) has weighed in on a determination of need application, saying in a letter to the state Department of Public Health (DPH) that BCH's expansion could increase spending by $8.5 million to $18.1 million annually for commercial payers in Massachusetts.
A news article in today's Boston Globe asks: "Is Children’s $1b project really necessary?" This is a pivotal question. Children's own data show that the demand for children's hospital care is declining both here and nationally. And, state data show Children’s already has the most expensive physician network in Massachusetts. So, why build? Globe reporter Priyanka McCluskey put that question to area health care experts and physicians at competing hospitals. Read on to find out what they had to say.
Boston Children’s Hospital’s (BCH) proposed $1 billion expansion project is explicitly designed to serve international and out-of-state patients, with no clear need for its planned services among Massachusetts families, according to a new analysis commissioned by the hospital by order of the state Department of Public Health (DPH). The report also concluded that a five-year trend of declining patient volumes at BCH is expected to continue into the foreseeable future.
This week, the Ten Taxpayer Group sent a letter to the Health Policy Commission (HPC), asking them to request a change in the scope of the Hospital's required cost analysis. The letter outlines a number of "grievous inadequacies" of the scope, analyses which they believe would shed light on the true financial implications of the expansion project, especially as it impacts health care costs in Massachusetts.
Massachusetts is at risk of approving the largest hospital construction project in state history, an expensive $1 billion building in the heart of the congested Longwood Medical Area. The proposal, by Boston Children’s Hospital, rests on ephemeral, shifting rationales that deserve in-depth scrutiny by state regulators.
The Prouty Garden is a vital, integral part of daily life at BCH, especially for the children and families who are inpatient. Kristina, Owen's mom, says the Prouty Garden is what Owen looks forward to every day. She shared this wonderful, touching video of Owen enjoying two simple things — sun on his face and water on his feet — on the July 4th holiday, a day when many people were out enjoying those same things. Except Owen got to do so while still inpatient within the confines the country's leading pediatric hospital.
In an update to our legal efforts, Judge Kenneth W. Salinger of the Suffolk Superior Court recently ruled to allow the core claim of our ten taxpayer group to move forward, denying the hospital's motion to dismiss. According to our lawyer, “It’s mostly good news for the Friends of Prouty Garden because the lawsuit against Children’s Hospital is intact and it goes forward."
